Inaugural
Issue: Belfast In Europe
(Vol 1, No 1)
“Hubert Butler’s works warn that a debate about
whether Ireland should become American or Swedish is missing
the point – his point. Beware of enthusiasm for distant
abstractions, at the cost of close and familiar details. Never
mind America and Sweden: Ireland has not yet become Irish, until
the alienation between majorities and minorities has been overcome
in a new sense of community. There is a world to win. But there
is also a family of neighbours down the road, and unfinished
business with them. Hubert Butler enjoyed history’s proxy
ironies. But not that Irish history should now repeat itself
inside out: that one part of Ireland should again march away
and sign up under the flag of some vaster identity – and
leave the other part forgotten in the rain. Yes, there is a
threat to Ireland’s ‘unique identity’ –
but it’s to the identity which has not yet been created.”
From “Unfinished
Ireland: Hubert Butler's Contemporary Relevance,” by Neal
Ascherson
The Justice Issue
(Vol 1, No 2)
“A couple of days after the attacks
of September 11th I talked on the phone with two American friends
who chanced to be on holiday in Florence at the time. Dismayed
like everybody else at what had happened, missing ‘the
reciprocity of tears’ that would have been more richly
available at home, they were finding that the best way to deal
with the desolation in America was to keep doing the things
that they had come to Italy to do. Their way of getting through
those days was to seek out and look hard at pictures and sculptures
that kept standing their ground, as it were, in spite of the
shaken state of the world around them …
My friends were wanting art to hold
up at the moment when they were being most borne down upon.
They had a stake in its worth being proved in extremis since
they are a couple who have lived lives based on the humanist
wager. They know not to expect uplift from art, but they also
expect not to be let down by it. And it was because of this
knowledge and their unreadiness to renege on it that I found
myself saying, not for the first time, that in these extreme
cases the challenge faced by the artist – and hopefully
also by the policy-makers – is the one W.B. Yeats formulated
so plainly in his introduction to A Vision: ‘to hold in
a single thought reality and justice.’”
From “Reality and
Justice: On Translating Horace,” by Seamus Heaney